Theatre Review – Lady  Chatterley’s Lover by Sheffield Theatres and English Touring Theatre


Mellors (Jonah Russell) and Constance Chatterley (Hedydd Dylan), Photograph by Mark Douet

Phillip Breen’s adaptation honours D. H. Lawrence’s overriding reach for tenderness in the love story that scandalised the western world after thirty-two years whispering under the sheets of Italian, French and Australian publishers.

Constance (Hedydd Dylan) and Clifford (Eugene O’Hare) Chatterley are a connected couple. They match, they make sense, they communicate. From the first appearance, Constance’s marital duty weighs visibly on her. She is resigned, dignified and practical. Despite their fresh physical hurdles, her intimacy with Clifford is established immediately through the tender and knowing handling of daily ablutions and conversation; this is not a marriage one would foresee breaking down. Clifford is ostensibly progressive and accepting, raising the suggestion himself that Constance should take a lover, or indeed do whatever is necessary to maintain her own emotional wellbeing in order that their marriage survive.

Inevitably there are unspoken stipulations attached to the contract, not unlike modern arguments surrounding situational abortion rights – a woman has the right to [blank], unless/only if it involves [blank] – which are the undoing of Clifford both for himself and for the audience.

Away then from the restrictions and disclaimers of the Chatterleys’ household and into the freedom of their grounds – a borderless Eden in which Constance and groundskeeper Mellors (Jonah Russell) share everything as innocents – at first a stuttering physical connection, later their full hearts and promises.

Laura Hopkins’ design complements the emotional subtlety of the tale beautifully; flowers, water and projection are used to magical effect. The play opens with Constance moving among neglected furniture covered with dustsheets, fronting darker depths of the stage reigned off with a simple white curtain that is later drawn open to reveal more private quarters of Mellors’ home and heart. David Osmond’s piano playing also enhances the delicacy of the piece. Natasha Chivers’ golden-hour lighting provides a perfectly stifling yet hopeful atmosphere for this story of impossible love overwhelmed by societal pressures and spiritual expectations. The looming shadow behind Constance’s first moment of nudity serves to heighten the complex blend of vulnerability and responsibility, while streams of running water like glittering thread melt any sense of wrong-doing in the lovers’ domain.

The working-vs-upper-classes thread is the weaker link, with fight sequences proving too cautious to pack any punch, although the power of the divide is felt sorely in sympathy for Constance’s dreams of her future with Mellors. There is a small sense of trouble to come in the prowess of Mellors’ arrival, although his presence lacks weight after this point with the dynamic being carried by Dylan.

Lady Chatterley’s Lover is playing at York Theatre Royal until Saturday 29th October and is well worth your time. You can see it at 2pm/7pm tomorrow or 2:30pm/7:30pm on Saturday. Tickets are available here:

You may like this if you enjoyed American Beauty, Revolutionary Road, or Testament of Youth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s